Case Name :      Helen Drinan: Giving Voice to Her Values (A)

Authors :           Mary L. Shapiro, Cynthia A. Ingols, Mary C. Gentile

Source :             North American Case Research Association (NACRA)

Case ID :            NA0144

Discipline :        Organizational Behavior

Case Length :    04 pages

Solution sample availability : YES

Plagiarism : NO (100% Original work)

In early 2006, Helen Drinan, Senior Vice President of Human Resources, Caritas Christi Health Care System (CCHCS), Boston, received two sexual harassment charges against the organization’s CEO and President, Robert Haddad. While she knew she was legally charged with acting, she faced a complicated situation: one, the hospital system was owned and operated by the Archdiocese of Boston with Cardinal O’Malley as the Chairman of the Board for the system; and two, these charges came after the priest molestation cases which rocked the Catholic Church of Boston. In Case A, Drinan presented the well-documented results from an independent investigator into the sexual harassment charges against Haddad. Although Drinan’s investigator presented clear evidence as to Haddad’s guilt, the Cardinal decided to launch a second investigation, using the Church’s lawyers. Drinan, interpreting this action as a delaying or avoidance tactic, decided that she must act. But, what should she say, to whom and how should she frame this critical conversation? In Case B, students read the letter Drinan sent to O’Malley, voicing her values. There is an extensive Epilogue that the instructor can report from or hand out to students that brings the case to a conclusion.